Three women of St Kilda cemetery

One of the pleasures of walking the suburbs  is making unexpected connections. Sometimes it’s a ghostsign – like the ‘Dr Morse’ sign that I first noticed in North Melbourne, which popped up again in Fitzroy and on a cafe wall in Abbotsford. Sometimes an architectural feature – the ‘barley sugar’ columns that I was unaware of until I spotted them on 1930s flats in South Yarra now keep turning up everywhere. And sometimes it’s a person whose life I find myself intersecting with as I walk. Whether we realise it or not, a passage through the city is a succession of encounters with countless individuals, celebrated, notorious or unknown. 

One of these is Dame Mabel Brookes, the Melbourne writer whom I first came across in the unlikely setting of the Maribyrnong Explosives Factory, which I wrote about here. The factory employed thousands of people, mainly women, during World war 2 and beyond. Brookes, a well-known figure in Melbourne’s upper class, worked on the production line for a few months as part of her war work in the 1940s, using the name ‘Mrs Brookes’, and included a brief account of life in the factory in one of her memoirs, Crowded Galleries.

I doubt the book is much read these days (I came across it quoted by John Lack in his history of Footscray) but as far as I know Brookes was the only contemporary writer to record life in the Maribyrnong explosives factory. In doing so she captured  a slice of working class history.

munitions-workers

“We worked swiftly. An armful of detonators, a line of boxes to be packed, a quick fitting of the deadly little grenades on one table, a careful manipulation of pins and tighter screwing of base plugs further down, a powder-filling section next door … The explosive factory was divided into a series of bays spreading like a town over the slopes, concrete paths joining the places of work. Ever present were the red lines showing where only the specially shod feet must tread …” – Mabel Brookes, Crowded Galleries

Mabel’s husband was Norman Brookes, another name not very well known today, except to tennis tragics. Norman was a bona fide champion, the first Australian winner of Wimbledon (which he won twice, in 1907 and 1914) and a world number one. The trophy they hand out every year at the Australian Open, to be held aloft by the likes of Djokovic and Federer, is the Norman Brookes Challenge Cup. So the equivalent of Mabel Brookes’ war work in our own day might be, say, Bec Hewitt, wife of Lleyton,  rocking up at the factory in her Mercedes.

When walking through South Yarra, which for many years has been thick with mansions, I came across ‘Raveloe’ where Mabel grew up, “the place of many parties and much fun and carefree youth”.

Raveloe

‘Raveloe’, where Mabel Brookes grew up in South Yarra

I imagined her getting into her chauffeur-driven car on that pleasant street beside the idyllic Domain – or perhaps one of her other houses, nearby ‘Kurnah’ – and driving across to smokey Maribyrnong, where she joined the women of the western suburbs making bombs and grenades. She didn’t have much in common with them – she was chums with colonels and generals, and she was president of the Victoria Hospital – but her memoir provides a valuable record of life at the factory (among a lot of other guff about tennis tournaments, society weddings and royal garden parties.).

Our paths crossed again on my most recent walk, when I wandered through St Kilda cemetery. Here is where Norman and Mabel Brookes’s journey came to an end. They share a gravestone in the cemetery. Perhaps surprisingly, no mention is made of Norman’s tennis achievements.

Brookes-grave

Not far from the Brookes’ grave is that of Sybil Craig, a Melbourne artist whose work I have come across from time to time (once, years ago, when I was planning a novel about the Melbourne art world, I read her diaries in the State Library). She too turned up at the Maribyrnong Explosives Factory, when she was appointed an official war artist.

Craig’s paintings of the factory capture in paint what Brookes captured in words:  the workers concentrating on their task (one moment of carelessness could have deadly consequences) the noise and the stink. The paintings can be viewed at the Australian War Memorial.

Sybil_Craig_ordnance_factory

Stories of war are usually told by men about men’s deeds. But these two women, ironically both from the eastern suburbs, and both far from working class, illuminate an aspect of Melbourne suburban life during the war which might otherwise be forgotten.

*

There are other interesting tales to be found in St Kilda cemetery – how could there not be? Every cemetery is a great starting point for stories. Here, for example, you’ll find the grave of  Alfred  Deakin, one of the most remarkable figures in Australian history, who played a critical role in federation, and was three times prime minister – not that you would know it from his tombstone. Those people who like to add every tiny achievement to their LinkedIn profile should look at how people of real note do it.

Deakin-grave

Other graves lead you to ask: Who is interred here, what do their memorials tell us?

I couldn’t go past this memorial to a woman named Doleen La Barte, who died in  1920. The scale of it suggests a more than ordinary level of grief.

Doleen_grave

Doleen LaBarte would have been born roughly the same time as Mabel Brookes, and like her came from a well-off Melbourne family, but fate or chance had other things in mind for her. The cemetery guidebook describes Doleen as a ‘murder victim’. On searching for more information, I found that she had been shot and killed by her husband,  Thomas LaBarte, in Moss Vale, NSW in 1920.  LaBarte also killed a policeman at the scene, before telephoning the police station to announce “I have shot one policeman, and I will shoot them all”.  On looking up newspaper reports of the case, I realised that this too was a kind of war story.

When he was put on trial, La Barte’s defence was that he was suffering from ‘war strain’ due to his experiences in World War I, during which he attained the rank of major. He claimed that he was temporarily insane when he killed his wife.

Screen Shot 2016-05-11 at 10.29.50 PM

The Register (Adelaide) 6 April 1921. Source: Trove.

[‘Dr. William A. Morton (V.), said he had been for several years in France as
a medical officer with the A.I.F. His experience showed that the nervous system was greatly affected by war strain, especially in cases where men were blown up by high explosives. Sometimes the trouble took the form of acute mania. He had seen a good deal of accused after the major’s return from the front. LaBarte, who appeared to be suffering very much from war strain, was nervous and restless, and had a tremor in his hands. He was not then drinking. By Mr. Shand— Witness was not surprised when he read of the
tragedy.’]

The jury returned a verdict of manslaughter, and LaBarte escaped the noose for both killings. The press, ever sensitive to matters of mental illness, dubbed him ‘the demented major’. Doleen La Barte’s bereaved family erected a memorial to their only daughter in St Kilda cemetery.

Much of the time when I walk around the city I am struck by how much things have changed. In this case, though, almost 100 years later, it seems we have made little progress either in the treatment of mental illness or in reducing family violence.

*

More about St Kilda cemetery: ‘St Kilda cemetery an unlikely tour venue’ (Leader newspapers)

 

 

 

Advertisements

4 comments

  1. A few years ago I lived in an apartment on Hotham street a stones throw away from St Kilda cemetery and walked through the grounds on a number of occasions.

    It took me a while but I was eventually able to locate the grave of Sir Frederick Sargood (and his wife) – the first owner of the mansion Rippon Lea. Sargood was a big deal way back then, his funeral sounds like an interesting affair:

    “On a scorching day in Melbourne thousands watched his funeral procession, which included eight massed bands, 1200 cadets and a firing-party of 300. He was buried in St Kilda cemetery, where members of the Metropolitan Liedertafel, of which he had been president, sang Sullivan’s ‘The Long Day Closes'”.

    Surprisingly for such a notable figure the Sargood grave is a rather modest affair.

    Fascinating post Nick and very well written – thanks for posting it.

    1. Thank you! That Sargood funeral sounds like an amazing affair. Eight massed bands – wow! I guess if they spent all the money on the procession there wasn’t much left for the memorial!

  2. Very interesting. Stories beautifully linked by your imagination and understanding. I love the grave with the peace sign which is waiting for the second person. Such a great approach to life, and its passing.
    Dana

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s